Posts Tagged ‘iPlayer’

Top ten Android Apps I miss from my T-Mobile G1 (HTC Dream)

Friday, September 11th, 2009

So here’s the story. My G1 has stopped working and being in the USA at the moment I have to return it to the UK to be replaced, in the mean time I’ve found myself missing both it and the applications on it. I’ve really grown to love Android and the apps on it. In fact it has become something of a mobile computer to me. With the easy WiFi connectivity and built in GPS (and the help of Locale) I’ve found using WiFi hotspots almost as easy as having a (cheap) 3G connection. Of course being on a UK contract I’d rather not incur the massive roaming charges for data in the USA.

In the last few days as I’ve started to miss it I decided to write a ‘Top Ten Roundup’ with a difference, the top ten that I miss. I’ve reverted to my Windows Mobile smart-phone so I still have a few luxuries. I expect that I’ll mention several things which made me prefer my G1 to the HTC Hermes I was on. Firstly though I’ll compare a few core components that I miss.

  • The email program. When I first used Android I wasn’t that excited about the email app; sure, it had starring which Windows Mobile didn’t, but that was about it for me. However I’ve come to really appreciate the way it synchronises and the way that I can apply labels and generally use it as I do the computer front end. Windows Mobile makes me synchronise manually or set a time, this is nice and I used to find it very useful but I really appreciate being able to use Locale with the Gmail application to trigger synchronising only in a WiFi hotspot.
  • The contacts application. There are some trade-offs here. Windows Mobile supports a birthday for a contact, unless I’m severely blind my G1 does not. Windows mobile however attacks my contacts list on Gmail adding Mr’s and Mrs’s which in turn adds extra contacts. This is fixable, the G1 lack of birthdays will surely be fixed in a future release. Incidentally the birthdays can be shown on the calendar with a small work around. Simply go to the calendars listing under settings, click browse interesting calenders and find your birthdays under ‘More’.
  • The browser. I really miss the Android browser and its speed and zoom features.
  • Marketplace. Do I even need to say anything here? The ease and simplicity is so nice.

Now for my top ten list of Android applications that I miss.

  1. Locale. I had rules set up to do everything I needed all based on where I was. It came into extra brilliance while abroad where I couldn’t use my normal data connection.
  2. ConnectBot. Having a well rounded SSH application is essential.
  3. Android IRC. Who can exist without IRC? I mean, what true techie can exist without IRC? Android IRC supports SSL, multiple servers and message notification, what’s more it doesn’t die if you leave it and open other applications.
  4. AndNav. This is my most memory heavy application, it uses tiles instead of vectors so pre-download is essential for any sensible routing. Also routes are calculated away from the client which causes network use. However, all this is well known to the developers and is being worked on. I would personally love to see (for example) POI search for off-line (maybe import gpx POI’s). I would be even more excited to see off-line routing, maybe data sets could be split further just to contain roads with no additional data? However all the Windows Mobile alternatives that I’ve found have not done what I needed or had some major problems.
  5. Quickipedia. Wikipedia has become the defatico source of information these days. Want cable layouts? Check Wikipedia. Want information about a penguin that flies? Check Wikipeida. Having a mobile client is like carrying it around as a book… just without ink or weight or that book smell or worrying about pages falling out.
  6. Movie Finder. It’s great to be able to quickly find out the times of a movie or check which ones are on locally. This isn’t a new concept I know but I found this the easiest to use, far easier than my previous experiences on Windows Mobile.
  7. Telegraph.co.uk news. Although this requires a connection and can’t horde its data off-line it’s still a great application. I’ve used other news applications and I’m open to suggestions but I found this to be the best. I do miss Viigo.
  8. Listen. I’d only just started using this but I’d become adicted pretty quickly. It’s a nice product from google themselves and it provides me with a stream of podcasts straight to my device. What’s more it can be run offline.
  9. FML. This would be one of two things that I use to entertain myself.
  10. Lolcats. This would be the other.

There are more I miss, there are more I used regularly and there are more I’d probably like to put on this list in the future. A couple in the running were:

  • My Tracks. A GPS tracking application that I’ve found to be absolutely excellent.
  • Beeb Player. BBC iPlayer application, not much use here as I have a US IP but it was great when I was in the UK.
  • Meridian Player (and now Meridian Evolve). A great player. Unfortunately I don’t watch much on my phone as my laptop has a better resolution for that.
  • Dizzler. A music on demand player, very useful for those moments where someone doesn’t know a song and you want to *show* them.
  • Barcode Scanner. Most sites about Android offer 2d encoded barcodes for content, I think this is a great way to move stuff from one device to another.
  • Better Keyboard. A great on screen keyboard. I certainly miss it.

That just about makes up my little Android tear story. Hopefully I should see a new G1 working perfectly within the next few weeks and I’ll be able to tell you which applications I’m adicted to right from the word go.

Kind regards, Robert.

  • Share/Bookmark

HP Pavillion DV7 2050ea and Linux.

Friday, September 4th, 2009

I am now a fortunate owner of an HP Pavillion DV7 2050ea. The first thing I’d like to say is that this is a very nice laptop and I’m very happy with almost every aspect. It’s comprised of the following hardware:

  • AMD Turion X2 Dual-Core Mobile ZM84, 2.3GHz
  • 4GB of RAM, I haven’t checked the brand but it seems fast
  • 320GB of hard drive space on a Western Digital drive
  • ATI M92 (Mobility Radeon 4500 series, 4530), seems to have 512MB of RAM
  • eSATA, USB and FireWire
  • ExpressCard
  • XD/MMC/SD slot
  • HDMI and VGA
  • QuickDock (v3 I think)

HP Blurb

The biggest problem so far has been the graphics card, so far I’ve been unable to get it working with fglrx. I have the standard X drivers working and they give me full screen output but that too was a bit of a fight. However under Vista the card seems incredibly powerful for a laptop and it has no problems playing DVDs using the standard X drivers under Linux. However the iPlayer will not play without major chopping. Hulu plays but only at standard resolution and without full screen.

The sound works perfectly using the snd_hda_intel module and one small adjustment to its config. In fact I’m quite impressed with the volume and power the speakers can create. The file /etc/modprobe.d/alsa-base.conf now contains:

options snd-hda-intel model=hp-hdx

eSATA, USB and FireWire all appear to work correctly. All I’ve noticed is that the eSATA port’s USB functionality seems to be a little low power, I can use everything except for hard drives which act as if I’d plugged them into a USB 1.1 port.

Strangely I can’t get the XD/SD etc slot to work, this is pretty normal though so I’m not too bothered. It does seem to help if I disable the power saving for them and FireWire in the BIOS. No idea why, maybe someone else will have more information on this.

The laptop can take two hard drives and I’ve found a second miniPCIe slot. Unfortunately the second hard drive needs a ‘kit’ to be installed, I’ll blog more about this when I get a chance to install one. However, with hard drives the size they are these days this makes for at least 1TB of space without too much heat overload.

I haven’t yet worked out the obligiroy IrDA, it seems it’s somehow hooked through the BIOS to allow the included remote to function (including the luxury of a power button). I haven’t had any other problems with it yet, the ExpressCard slot seems to work perfectly as do the other various ports.

Over all this is an excellent laptop with a lot of power, although it’s large enough to watch DVDs on it is also small enough and light enough to be portable.

Kind regards, Robert.

  • Share/Bookmark

Review of the iPlayer – Round two (does it still judder?)

Sunday, January 18th, 2009

This seems like a good time to write another iPlayer review, after all, they’ve had some time and I have a new computer. What’s changed?

So, let’s look at what we said last time.

Good

  • No advertisements (other than a brief channel trailer which doesn’t really count).
  • Good quality, especially for so called ’standard definition’.
  • Generally fast play.
  • Done with flash, pretty much universal.

Bad

  • Bandwidth heavy.
  • No live viewing.
  • Some issues with the video.
  • Only seven days of watching time.
  • Awful problems with full screen play.

The thing is that I now have a computer which is almost as good as my Dad’s media machine. This means that I can experiment more, but it doesn’t mean that I have something more powerful than the box I tested it on before (although the screen is a tad smaller).

However, Auntie has had a chance to get her act together and upgrade/advance the iPlayer. This seems to have resulted in some serious interface changes and the new high definition version.

I don’t have time to write a full review at the moment but here’s my summary:

Bad to good

  • With the introduction of the HD version bandwidth seems to have dropped for the non-HD media, unfortunately so has quality (see below).
  • Since my last exploration I’ve found some programs and libraries which allow iPlayer downloading.
  • It would seem that more and more applications are supporting the iPlayer (Boxee and XBMC).

Good to bad

  • The quality before HD was very good on normal recordings. It would seem that with HD’s introduction the SD (standard definition) media is lower quality and in general more flaky.

New bad

  • Over the last few weeks I’ve encountered a few video bugs, mostly involving jerks or artifacts.
  • Occasionally the video decides to scramble audio and play at ten times speed, similar things happened before but this is worse.
  • I’ve started to notice that very little of the audio is normalised, I have to adjust my amp a lot.
  • Contrast and brightness differences, hitting ‘auto calibrate’ a lot on my screen isn’t much fun.

New good

  • The HD version is very nice and the content very crisp.
  • There is a growing number of devices which support the iPlayer.
  • The ability to pause, then resume the next time you open your browser (it remembers where you were), a small but important improvement.
  • Wider range of Programme avaliability.
  • I can generally get jerk-less full screen playback on my box. I have yet to purchase a non-integrated graphics card so this is impressive (I have a NVIDIA internal at the moment).

Still good

  • No advertisements. Even with things like Heroes there are no advertisements, the most you get is a channel/producer trailer.
  • Audio on both SD and HD is crisp and clear.
  • Generally very good avaliability.
  • Generally fast play.
  • Good support for most normal computers.

Still bad

  • No live viewing that I can find.
  • Limited time to watch.
  • Strange problems with full screen, sometimes on some computers with some definitions. They’ve certainly fixed it for some situations.

I think that  covers just about everything, feel free to comment with your own opinions.

Kind regards, Robert.

  • Share/Bookmark

The iPlayer

Thursday, April 3rd, 2008

I think most people who’ve been following the iPlayer in any depth have noticed that it’s not really delivering. It has some good sides, but there are a fair few things that I’d like to take issue with.

BBC iPlayer main page

I would not say it’s been a complete waste of money, it hasn’t. It provides videos to anyone within a certain part of the desktop market’s spectrum. So, what’s bad about it? Primarily, you may not download the videos if you’re on anything other than Windows. Isn’t this government backing of a monopoly? Annoyingly the online viewing is only available for 6 days, and even if you do find that old XP disk you’ll only be able to keep the videos for 30 days. So much for asking your neighbours to download a year’s worth of East Enders for you while you’re off on that gap year in Tibet.

BBC iPlayer shows it’s true colours.

So, if you use Linux and you’re away from a computer for more than 7 days, tough.

It does provide some good quality video, the screen shot above shows a similar quality to what you’ll generally get. How much of a good thing is this though? If we dub this ‘high definition’, where’s the standard definition or low definition version for those of us on slower and more expensive connections?

Whatever codec they’re using (I haven’t researched, maybe someone can fill me in) seems to be quite high on the bandwidth usage. They also don’t seem to be using the standard method of scaling videos; normally videos will scale nicely to full screen on any of my computers (on youtube and the like), iPlayer doesn’t. I get skips, jumps, hops and judders if I try to full screen it. I’ve tested it on this machine (1.7GHz, 1GB), my other laptop (1.6GHz, 2GB), and my dad’s media machine (2x 2.6GHz, 2GB). All had problems.

It also has a habit of killing itself out of the blue. This generally manifests itself in one of several ways:

  • ‘There has been a problem playing this video…’ This tends to happen when you walk away for a while and then come back.
  • ‘Undefined undefined undefined’ This has only ever happened once, but I presume heavier users get it more often.
  • The jitters. This is when suddenly everything goes jittery, something like a deliberate echo 0.5s after and at the same volume.
  • The express joo-jars. An apt nickname for when it goes into super fast mode and does something weird with the sound.

BBC iPlayer dies!

BBC iPlayer dies again!

In general it behaves, but I’ve noticed a few other distinct problems:

  • Incomplete uploads. An absolute curse, generally it will finish just before the bit which finalises the whole program.
  • Time delay. For some reason they seem to forget to upload half the days programs for a while, perfectly OK until you want to watch one which is missing.

All in all though, it’s not all bad. I’ll try a comparison with a competitor, ITV’s catchup.

Downloads: [BBC] Yes, only Windows and for 30 days. [ITV] No, or invisible.

Video quality: High, sharp and generally smooth. Nasty.

Adverts: None, just a channel trailer at the beginning. Lots.

Requirements: Flash and a browser. Internet Explorer, a ‘patched’ Windows Media Player, ActiveX.

Speed: Fast. Slow to start with then seems to be buffered and OK.

Watching live: No known mechanism. Possible, reasonable quality.

At the end of the day, does it let me watch Dr Who? Yes, therefore it can’t be all bad.

Kind regards, Robert.

  • Share/Bookmark